City University of Hong Kong CLASS CLASS
Making Sense of Grammar
1 like 0 dislike
How to express time phrases in Chinese: Why is the sentence *我吃早飯在八點 ungrammatical?
asked Apr 10, 2018 in Questions about Chinese Grammar by admin (25,520 points)
edited Apr 26, 2018 by admin | 562 views

1 Answer

0 like 0 dislike

For ungrammatical sentence like "*我吃早飯在八點", it is firstly a kind of negative transfer from their mother tongue English that causes the error. Since in English the normal form of this sentence is "I get up at 8 o’clock." The preposition "at" in English is obligatory here to signal "time", but in Chinese,  "在" cannot exist before temporal adverbial except for the ‘在…的時候’ structure. 

Secondly, time adverbs are commonly placed before the verb in Chinese, so here, by placing "8點" before the verb, we can get "八點我吃早飯" and "我八點吃早飯", and both are acceptable. Compare these two sentences, the default form is the second one, and by moving the time adverb to the front, we topicalized the time "八點", and thus the time here becomes more important in pragmatic level.

Statistics shows that, time adverbials can normally appear at the beginning, in the middle and at the end of the sentence in English, and to place them at the end is the most common way.

Now I feel it’s very easy to get inside.

Career women now shop at couture.

"I removed them all," the doctor declared, "we’ll close now."

While in Chinese they usually precede the verb that they modify and are placed before or after the sentence subject, with different pragmatic focuses, while the possibility of using which one of them is relatively equal.



To place the time adverbs at the sentence final position is rare, and thus it is the more marked way for temporal adverbials in Chinese for some specific meanings or in special structure.


answered Apr 10, 2018 by admin (25,520 points)

1,614 questions

1,882 answers


15,645 users

1,614 questions
1,882 answers
15,645 users